It has been over three months since my last blog was published. The reason for this writing gap is that my wife and I have been very busy. In early August, my brother and sister-in-law came to visit us in our British Columbia (BC) condo. A few days later, my wife’s niece and her family visited us for a week. Three days later, we flew to London for a 70th birthday party and afterwards, toured the Scottish Highlands for almost two weeks.
After returning to BC in mid-September, we packed our household goods, closed on the sale of our BC condo, and drove south across the Canadian border to Austin. The sale of our Canada condo was a very sad occasion as we dearly loved spending summers there. The reasons for selling our condo were primarily the increasing costs for foreigners to own Canadian property. During the pandemic, the BC Provincial government imposed a “speculation” tax on non-Canadians who owned property in designated urban regions. We lived just south of Sidney, a small town north of Victoria. For some reason, our property was included in the speculation tax region.
The BC speculation tax started at 1% of the property value, per year; a tax in addition to the assessed property tax. The BC government later increased the tax to 2%. To make matters worse, the Canadian Federal government enacted an Underused Housing Tax (UHT) assessed at 1%. Underused is defined as living in the property less than six months per year. Non-Canadians are prohibited from staying in Canada for more than six months a year. This is a nice way of not stating the true intention of the tax. Thus, our additional property taxes rose to 3%.
There was no grandfathering for foreign owners who purchased property prior to the start of the speculation and UHT taxes. The Federal government also banned all new foreign purchases of Canadian property. These laws were passed when the BC and Federal governments were ruled by the Liberal Party. The stated purpose of the speculation and UHT taxes was to decrease the cost of Canadian housing in urban areas. Canadians who owned multiple properties were also taxed but at a reduced level.
We paid the yearly speculation and UHT taxes with the hope that the BC and federal government would change their policy. When the economist Mark Carney was elected Prime Minister, his government wisely eliminated the UHT. However, the BC government raised their speculation tax to 3% in 2026 and 4% in 2027. This change resulted in our decision to sell our condo in early July. The high speculation tax made no financial sense since the US property taxes were much lower, no matter how much we loved our property. Our auto insurance rates also tripled during the pandemic due to the change in BC policy. All foreign car owners were insured at the highest rate rather than by their individual driving record. Without bluntly saying it, the BC government wanted seasonal residents to leave Canada. Their non-resident taxation policies began during the Biden administration, well before the second Trump administration’s tariffs and disrespectful behavior towards Canadians. It applied to all foreigners, not just Americans.
Canadian housing prices did decline from their 2022 peak. The BC government achieved their stated purpose of lowering housing costs. However, the real reason for the housing shortage was the Federal government’s immigration policy which recently brought 1.5 million legal immigrants into Canada. There was not enough low income housing available in Canada for such a large influx of immigrants. This caused the sudden increase in urban housing costs. Governments cannot publicly blame their immigration policies as this would cause the government to fall. It was much easier to blame non-residents who don’t vote. Our condo was not low-income housing and only Canadians were allowed to purchase it, thus reducing the number of potential buyers. The economic theory of supply and demand does work in practice, both for good and poor governmental policies.
After we departed Canada, the BC Liberal Party called a snap election because the Conservative Party was fractured. Six weeks later, the Conservative Party routed the Liberal Party and now runs the BC government. Voters witnessed the faulty Liberal Party policies and voted for change. Even if the speculation tax is reversed, it will take years for foreigners to trust the BC government.
The other reason for selling our BC condo was personal. My daughter, her husband, and three grandchildren live in Rochester (NY). Upstate New Year also has moderate summer weather. The total cost of leasing a nice Rochester apartment was less expensive than the BC speculation tax alone, without the added burden of maintenance, taxes, and owning a BC car. We can invest the condo capital rather than have the capital tied up in the declining Canadian real estate market. Moving to Rochester made both economic and personal sense. Government policy does have consequences, as people have options.
We flew to Rochester on Halloween and the following Monday we moved into our apartment about 15 minutes from my daughter’s home. Our Canadian furniture was sold with the condo, so we had to start from scratch. The past week was a frenzy of unpacking boxes and shopping for furniture. Today, we are unpacked and have purchased most of our furnishings. Our new apartment is starting to look and feel like home, although the northeast cold winter begins soon. We will depart for Austin in a few days and return next Spring.
Moving is stressful, tiring, and chaotic. It is one of my least favorite activities. Saying goodbye to our close Canadian neighbors was painful. Connecting to a new community is uncomfortable and feels awkward at first. Change is part of life, with both good and bad experiences.
We attended my daughter’s Presbyterian church on All Saints Day. As I sat with my daughter’s family inside this magnificent gothic church, I started to feel God’s Spirit. In John chapters 14–16, Jesus speaks about the promise of the Holy Spirit, which he describes as an Advocate or Comforter. “And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Advocate, to be with you forever.” (John 14:16)
No matter where you move, the Advocate is with you. “This is the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor knows him. You know him, because he abides with you, and he will be in you.” (John 14:17) Wherever I move, I am always at home because the Spirit abides with me. My surroundings change, but the Spirit is eternal and unchanging. It will “teach you everything, and remind you of all that I have said to you.” (John 14:26)












